Differences in accounts and the ‘lying’ complainant: a qualitative study of rape trials from Victoria, Australia

It is now well recognised that victims of sexual offences may recount events differently at different times and to different audiences and that variations, gaps or ‘inconsistencies’ are not necessarily indicative of lying or unreliability. Incorporating this knowledge into the criminal trial now for...

Full description

Saved in:  
Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Quilter, Julia (Author)
Contributors: McNamara, Luke ; Porter, Melissa
Format: Electronic Article
Language:English
Published: 2023
In: International journal of law, crime and justice
Year: 2023, Volume: 73
Online Access: Volltext (lizenzpflichtig)
Volltext (lizenzpflichtig)
Journals Online & Print:
Drawer...
Check availability: HBZ Gateway
Keywords:
Cross-examination
Inconsistencies
Jury directions
Rape law reform
Rape trials

MARC

LEADER 00000naa a22000002 4500
001 1869892127
003 DE-627
005 20231109142426.0
007 cr uuu---uuuuu
008 231109s2023 xx |||||o 00| ||eng c
024 7 |a 10.1016/j.ijlcj.2023.100593  |2 doi 
035 |a (DE-627)1869892127 
035 |a (DE-599)KXP1869892127 
040 |a DE-627  |b ger  |c DE-627  |e rda 
041 |a eng 
084 |a 2,1  |2 ssgn 
100 1 |a Quilter, Julia  |e VerfasserIn  |4 aut 
245 1 0 |a Differences in accounts and the ‘lying’ complainant  |b a qualitative study of rape trials from Victoria, Australia  |c Julia Quilter, Luke McNamara, Melissa Porter 
264 1 |c 2023 
336 |a Text  |b txt  |2 rdacontent 
337 |a Computermedien  |b c  |2 rdamedia 
338 |a Online-Ressource  |b cr  |2 rdacarrier 
520 |a It is now well recognised that victims of sexual offences may recount events differently at different times and to different audiences and that variations, gaps or ‘inconsistencies’ are not necessarily indicative of lying or unreliability. Incorporating this knowledge into the criminal trial now forms part of the wider reform agenda in a number of jurisdictions, including via recommended jury directions. This is now expressly reflected in provisions like s 54D of the Jury Directions Act 2015 (Vic) - introduced in 2017 - which provides for an educative direction on how the jury should (and should not) consider differences in the complainant's account. Drawing on rare access to sexual offence trial transcripts, this article reports on the findings of an analysis of 33 rape trials finalised in the County Court of Victoria between 2013 and 2020. We found that complainants were still regularly cross-examined, and the quality of their evidence challenged, on the basis of differences in their accounts. We found little evidence that the availability of a jury direction has shifted the defence practice of evoking the ‘lying complainant’ by pointing to ‘inconsistences’ in their evidence. 
650 4 |a Cross-examination 
650 4 |a Inconsistencies 
650 4 |a Jury directions 
650 4 |a Rape law reform 
650 4 |a Rape trials 
700 1 |a McNamara, Luke  |e VerfasserIn  |0 (DE-588)130059153  |0 (DE-627)488797845  |0 (DE-576)297974750  |4 aut 
700 1 |a Porter, Melissa  |e VerfasserIn  |4 aut 
773 0 8 |i Enthalten in  |t International journal of law, crime and justice  |d Oxford : Elsevier, 2008  |g 73(2023), Artikel-ID 100593  |h Online-Ressource  |w (DE-627)559427743  |w (DE-600)2412511-8  |w (DE-576)278242537  |x 1756-0616  |7 nnns 
773 1 8 |g volume:73  |g year:2023  |g elocationid:100593 
856 4 0 |u https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijlcj.2023.100593  |x Resolving-System  |z lizenzpflichtig  |3 Volltext 
856 4 0 |u https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1756061623000198  |x Verlag  |z lizenzpflichtig  |3 Volltext 
936 u w |d 73  |j 2023  |i 100593 
951 |a AR 
ELC |a 1 
LOK |0 000 xxxxxcx a22 zn 4500 
LOK |0 001 4404402929 
LOK |0 003 DE-627 
LOK |0 004 1869892127 
LOK |0 005 20231109095606 
LOK |0 008 231109||||||||||||||||ger||||||| 
LOK |0 040   |a DE-21-110  |c DE-627  |d DE-21-110 
LOK |0 092   |o n 
LOK |0 852   |a DE-21-110 
LOK |0 852 1  |9 00 
LOK |0 935   |a krzo 
ORI |a WA-MARC-krimdoka001.raw