RT Article
T1 Does Gender Affect Judges’ Perceptions of Sexual Assault Cases?
JF Journal of interpersonal violence
VO 38
IS 1/2
SP 466
OP 508
A1 Burgstedt, Corinna
A1 Beeby, Amy
A1 Hayne, Harlene
A1 Hobbs, Linda
A1 Gross, Julien
A1 Patterson, Tess
A2 Beeby, Amy
A2 Hayne, Harlene
A2 Hobbs, Linda
A2 Gross, Julien
A2 Patterson, Tess
LA English
YR 2023
UL https://krimdok.uni-tuebingen.de/Record/1830284460
AB There is growing recognition that females engage in harmful sexual behaviour that is similar in severity and type to males. Existing research, however, suggests that there is a bias towards leniency in judicial systems for female sexual offenders (FSOs) in comparison to male sexual offenders (MSOs). Specifically, FSOs receive shorter sentences than do MSOs and are less likely to be sentenced to prison. The majority of research examining disparity in sentence outcomes for FSOs have been analysed through a quantitative lens. Qualitative methodology is also needed to understand any subjective differences in the way that judges perceive case-relevant factors and whether these perceptions differ as a function of the offender’s gender. The present study is a qualitative study that examined judges’ perceptions and descriptions of FSO compared to MSO in 10 matched cases of sexual offending. The study found that although there were many similarities in how judges perceived FSO compared to MSO, there were also unique differences that could explain more lenient sentences for FSOs (i.e. the vulnerability, poor mental health and adverse backgrounds of FSOs). Other unique differences found were that judges’ perception of FSOs behaviour was described as depraved and cruel, whereas MSOs similar behaviour was not described in such an emotive way. The present study provides additional insight into the reasons for a bias towards leniency for FSOs. In particular, it points towards judicial focus on particular personal circumstances that are seen as relevant in sentencing FSOs but not for MSOs.
K1 judges’ perceptions
K1 Sentencing
K1 Gender disparity
K1 male sexual offending
K1 female sexual offending
DO 10.1177/08862605221085034